When a Later EICR Differs From an Earlier Report
How to record current findings when an EICR differs from older paperwork.
Written by
TestFast Team
Electrical testing software built by electricians, for electricians
A later EICR that records a different condition is not, by itself, proof that the earlier inspector missed a defect. Each report is an assessment of the installation at the time of that inspection, within its stated extent and limitations.
That distinction matters when a customer asks you to explain why two reports do not match. Your current report needs to describe what you inspected, what you found and what the evidence supports. It cannot reconstruct what another inspector saw or knew on an earlier visit.
What the current EICR can establish
Electrical Safety First’s Best Practice Guide 4 describes an EICR as an assessment of the installation’s current in-service condition against the edition of BS 7671 current at the inspection. The report records the extent inspected and tested, any limitations, and the results and observations for that inspection.
So read the report as a time- and scope-bounded record. A difference between two reports is a reason to look carefully at what each one actually covers; it is not an explanation of why the difference exists.
Keep the present findings separate from assumptions
For the inspection you are carrying out, record the condition you can establish. The guide says an observation should describe a specific defect, omission, damage or dangerous condition, and state what the situation is rather than what repair should be done.
Keep the observation tied to the relevant inspection or test result. Where scope or access limits what you could establish, the report should make those limitations clear. Use the evidence from the current inspection; do not turn a mismatch with an older document into a claim about the person who completed it.
What a difference cannot tell you
The later report does not, on its own, show:
- what the installation’s condition was at the date of the earlier inspection
- what parts of the installation the earlier inspector accessed, inspected or tested
- what information or limitations were recorded in the earlier report
- why the two reports differ, or whether anyone acted improperly
Those questions need evidence beyond the fact that the reports are different. The source for this article does not set out a procedure for comparing reports or deciding what happened at an earlier inspection, so this guide does not prescribe one.
Keep the report factual
The practical line is straightforward: report the installation you inspected, within the scope and limitations of that inspection. Describe each supported observation clearly and keep the conclusion within what the available evidence establishes.
For an explanation of how scope, readings and observations fit into a report, see our EICR report example. For classification-code explanations, see our EICR codes guide.
Ready to transform your EICR workflow?
Join hundreds of UK electricians who are saving hours on every report with TestFast.